After it is installed, Solver will. The automation of shift schedule with a minimum number of input parameters from the manager is an effective solution that will reduce the time taken by the manager for preparing the roster. A working day consists of 10 hours, from 10:00 till 20:00. Workforce sourcing can be challenging especially if your DC is surrounded by e-commerce fulfilment centres. I am trying to create a mathematical model for employee scheduling. Use MathJax to format equations. Your home for data science. Have you tried using MATLAB's mixed-integer linear programming solver for any of your own work? To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. To capture this correctly, we take a conservative approach. pywraplp is a Python wrapper for the underlying C++ solver. By contrast, studies of special cases reported over the past decade have focused on problems involving between 100 and 500 variables. A store sells two types of toys, A and B. We have taken maximization for the objective function because constraints will ensure that the minimum week offs are given for the associates, and if any shift has more associates working after the fulfilment of the minimum number of employee for the shift, it is a favorable outcome. It only takes a minute to sign up. Christian Reinsch, Roland Bulirsch, and the SVD, sinpi, cospi, implicit expansion and The 2022 MATLAB Mini-Hack, New Geometric Transformation Matrix Convention in R2022b, Tips and Tricks when Dealing with Callbacks in Simulink, Whats New in Interoperability with TensorFlow and PyTorch, Converting a Script to a Function Example, NASAs DART mission successfully slams asteroid, New Feature: ThingSpeak Now Supports Images, Startup Shorts: Automated Harvesting Robot by AGRIST is Solving Agriculture Problems. Click OK and then click Yes. Mobile app infrastructure being decommissioned. staffed 24 hours a day by a limited number of nurses. Constraint 2: Minimum working time by worker. intlinprog will give me my optimal x vector, but this is simply a long vector of of ones and zeros saying which shifts are implemented. Linear programming (LP) is one of the best methods to find optimal solutions for problems with constraints like the above. This free workbook contains seven example models from personnel scheduling. Do US public school students have a First Amendment right to be able to perform sacred music? By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. A working day consists of 10 hours, from 10:00 till 20:00. @Kuifje Thank you for your comment. For example we cannot assign morning shift to an employee on Tuesday if he had worked Evening shift on the previous. How to help a successful high schooler who is failing in college? Also, while it seems that JOHNSON has two shifts, this is because we are wrapping around and the shift actually goes from 10pm to 6am the next morning. Although I didn't use sparse matrices in this demo, intlinprog is capable of working with sparse matrices to make more efficient use of memory and allow for larger problem sizes. This paper illustrates how linear programming has been effectively used in Nurses scheduling at a multi-specialty Hospital in Coimbatore. To be sure, it takes a bit of study and experience to be able to know how to easily convert a real world problem into its equivalent MILP formulation. This constraints take care of assigning continuous shift to the employee. Make a wide rectangle out of T-Pipes without loops. Each employee should not work more than 5 working days continually. Broadcast scheduling (maximization) 56. Also, there are set of constraints, which has restrictions on what values the decision variables can take. Quickly linear programming became commonly used to: Her colleague from Shift 6 will start the week Saturday and get 2 days off on Thursday. Linear programming techniques have been . 4. In this section, we take the previous example and add nurse requests for specific shifts. Is MATLAB command "fourier" only applicable for continous-time signals or is it also applicable for discrete-time signals? Example 1 A store has requested a manufacturer to produce pants and sports jackets. is assigned to nurse n on day d and that nurse requested that problem. Linear Programming Examples. Enjoyed this content & want to support my channel? In this article, we will solve the linear programming problems using the graphucal method. Linear programming (LP) is one of the most important method to achieve the outcome of optimization problems. For example, the miminized cost is shown in the command window to be 4670.0 (in real-world terms, $4760 dollars in daily wages). This constraints take care of assigning continuous shift to the employee. If you are interested in that though, I definitely encourage you to download the MATLAB files for this example and check it out for yourself. And if you cannot generate all the feasible columns a priori you can do column generation (which does it dynamically). For that, I would need 7 columns. This paper illustrates how a linear programming solves the nurses scheduling problems. Here is the entire program for the nurse scheduling problem. For more flexibility, you will use 100% of temporary workers to build your team. This way in the A matrix I will have many columns with 0 as matrix Elements. Links below:Buy me a coffee: https://. I specify that all the decision variables are integers, and have a value between 0 and 1. Now such a schedule can start from 10:00 and is dependent on the working hours of that employee. You can use the worksheet that most closely models your situation as a starting point. Currently, many teams follow the manual process of preparing the roster with an excel sheet, however, this results in violation of certain constraints and a lot of manual effort to come up with an acceptable roster for the entire team. # Create the linear solver with the GLOP backend. Let's take a look at what's inside. This had been one of our most requested features, as MILP has trememdous application in a variety of areas such as scheduling and resource optimization. an optimal schedule (although perhaps not the only one). Even though there are some minor changes that the team might need to do on case to case basis manually, this program gives a skeleton of roster on which those minimum changes can be made, instead of preparing the schedule from scratch each time. There are two parts to the inequality constraint matrix A, which are clearly visible. Take for example a day. Sign up for the Google Developers newsletter. The number of workers needed will be given in th. ZoomShift is a scheduling tool for hourly employees. Java is a registered trademark of Oracle and/or its affiliates. Considering that the average productivity of your workers is stable, the only solution is to adapt your resources to meet the demand of each day. In geometry, linear programming analyzes the vertices of a polygon in the Cartesian plane. Search for jobs related to Employee scheduling linear programming example or hire on the world's largest freelancing marketplace with 19m+ jobs. But for problems like this, especially at larger problem sizes, attempting to solve it using other methods such trial-and-error or genetic algorithms will usually take longer, and generally not yield as good results. Starbucks employee Scheduling. I have already got an idea on how I should model it but I do not know whether it is the best way to do it so. This example has the same constraints as the previous example. Save and categorize content based on your preferences. There are three binary decision variables for each employee and for each of the day (for two shifts). shows which shift assignments were requested and the number of request that were met. The top portion has 24 rows (because there are 24 hours in a day) and each row represents the constraint that at a particular hour, you need a minimum number of staff. Schedule optimization is a class of problem that can be solved effectively with linear programming. Note that there are a couple of employees (ANDERSON and JACKSON) that do not get called in. The k-th row of this section is associated with the constraint that the k-th employee may only work one shift per day. Declare the solver. This is a fictional dataset and the Excel file is available along with the MATLAB code for this blog post so you can feel free to try it out on your own. Here is a list of the best work scheduling software for both hourly employees and salaried workforces. Specically, using the Simplex algorithm to solve the linear program, then rounding the continouous variables to discrete binary variables for Suppose there is an employee working for 4 hours. Here I used the spy function to view the sparsity pattern. Each associate should have at most one shift per day. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. The job shop problem. Cargo storage (maximization) 55. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. 2-1: Introduction. or 1, indicating whether a shift was requested. Additional information such as preferred shift for each of the employee on a particular day national holidays can be added to the program to handle specific cases. I will go back and find out which index of x corresponds with which employee and shift, and then display the data in a more human-friendly form. Constraint 3: Maximum working time by week. # Create the variables x and y. Site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Only one of the three variables are set to 1 for an employee in a day, because they can either work in morning shift, or in evening shift or can be on week off. The first sheet in the Excel file (available here) contains the staff information, and it is in a tabular format suitable to be imported directly as a MATLAB table using the readtable function. Generalize the Gdel sentence requires a fixed point theorem. Suppose a postman has to deliver 6 letters in a day from the post office (located at A) to different houses (U, V, W, Y, Z). As the number of employees and possible shifts increases, A may consist of many thousands of columns. We then look for a schedule that maximizes the number of requests that are met. The roster is typically prepared in the last week of the month for the next 5 to 6 weeks in advance, and also takes into account preference of the associates like planned leave, shift preferences on certain days, week off, the maximum number of consecutive days that the employee is working, etc. The drag and drop schedule builder simplifies the . Does squeezing out liquid from shredded potatoes significantly reduce cook time? Data envelopment analysis 49. Is there a more efficient way to model such a schedule? Methods of solving inequalities with two variables, system of linear inequalities with two variables along with linear programming and optimization are used to solve word and application problems where functions such as return, profit, costs, etc., are to be optimized. The decision variables and the constraints have to be correctly declared to yield the desired optimum results. Since it's introduction in release R2014a, we've had several blog posts now showing some applications of intlinprog , the mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) solver found in the Optimization Toolbox. Were powering the next great retail disruption. Without this constraint, the program continued to assign employees to the same shift across all the days of the month in which they were working. How to ensure that working hours for employee i come right after each other? For example, in A5, enter 1 to indicate that 1 employee begins work on Monday and works Monday through Friday. The preparation of a roster for a team is a time-consuming activity for the manager, when done manually, especially in teams with a large number of associates, where the manager has to give considerations to the preference of each employee. Therefore you need to ensure minimum working time for your temporary workers to be an attractive employer. Every column of A is also associated with a decision variable that we constrain to be either 0 or 1 (a binary variable). Each element of the triple is 0 The application of mathematical and systematic models and approaches to health is on the rise. this paper focuses on a constructive method for solving labor scheduling problem encountered in a construction company, suggesting an estimated labor cost over a week and the requirement of. ZoomShift. Especially if you're still manually creating the employee schedule, you open yourself up to scheduling problems, errors, and employee dissatisfaction. However, I do want to discuss briefly the structure of the constraint matrices and decision variables for this particular problem. The first shows the actual work schedule for each employee (blue indicates when on shift). Setting up objective function. There should be a rotation of shift after alternate weeks or after every two weeks. The distance between the houses is indicated on the lines as given in the image. Multiperiod workforce planning (minimization) 52. 2. The data for this example is shown below. The following code an array of variables for the Our aim is to maximize the value of Z (the profit). However, this sizing is not satisfying as we have 6 extra man days to add to our P&L because of Friday and Saturday. Pulp was able to solve the optimization problem within 2 minutes to an optimum solution. Solution Let x be the number of units of X produced in the current week y be the number of units of Y produced in the current week then the constraints are: 50x + 24y <= 40 (60) machine A time 30x + 33y <= 35 (60) machine B time x >= 75 - 30 The total daily wages the employer must pay out. A major challenge faced by Distribution Center (DC) managers is the fluctuation of the workload during the week. Textbooks: https://amzn.to/2VgimyJhttps://amzn.to/2CHalvxhttps://amzn.to/2Svk11kIn this video, I'll talk about how to formulate a special type of LP problem . Generate the f, A, and b matrices based on the the constraints and objectives, 3. This is by far the most tricky constrain to write. Read in the requirements and employee data from the Excel sheet 2. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Here, z stands for the total profit, a stands for the total number of toy A units and b stands for total number to B units. PuLP is a modelling framework for Linear (LP) and Integer Programming (IP) problems written in Python maintained by COIN-OR Foundation (Computational Infrastructure for Operations Research). Reason for use of accusative in this phrase? Now's let download the data mentioned at the beginning of the article . Why does Q1 turn on and Q2 turn off when I apply 5 V? You can select a web site from the following list: Accelerating the pace of engineering and science. There are several constraints that must be handled for a proper roster. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Call intlinprog with every variable as an integer 0 or 1, Office Assignments by Binary Integer Programming: Solver-Based, Office Assignments by Binary Integer Programming: Problem-Based, A list of employees with their available work hours, and hourly salaries, A prescibed minimum number of staff needed to be at work at a given hour (fewer staff are needed at night, more staff are needed during peak hours). I am returning two arguments, the first is the decision vector itself, x, and the second argument, cost, is the minimized daily cost associated with this solution. Employee scheduling. Optimize (Maximize or Minimize) Z = a 1 x 1 + a 2 x 1 + a 3 x 3 + + a n x n . The associates of different levels should be split evenly across the different shifts. The argument "GLOP" specifies GLOP, the OR-Tools linear solver. shift. Each nurse works at most one shift per day. Each day and each shift should satisfy minimum resource constraint. 1) OBJECTIVE FUNCTION: The objective function of an LPP (Linear Programming Problem) is a mathematical representation of the objective in terms of a measurable quantity such as profit, cost, revenue, etc. Obviously the "Nurse Scheduling Problem" is not limited to "nurses" as an occupation, so I will just use the generic term "employee" here. Each employee should work at most one shift per day. An example of the pattern schedule method is where every employee is off every 2nd weekend. If you need 31 workers Monday, you need to secure at least 31 workers for Monday. You can find the full code in this Github repository: Link.My portfolio with other projects: Samir Saci, 0 workers hired for Thursday and Saturday shifts, Friday: 1 extra worker Saturday: 5 extra workers. Except as otherwise noted, the content of this page is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License, and code samples are licensed under the Apache 2.0 License. Why are only 2 out of the 3 boosters on Falcon Heavy reused? 3:12. The specifics of this are covered thoroughly in the documentation. I don't need this to be table, I just want to import it as a numeric array, so xlsread will work just fine. The output Employee assignment (maximization) 48. The objective function that we are maximizing here is the level of the associate multiplied by the sum of the shift that they are working in. Proper scheduling can help optimize many avenues of business from staff scheduling to fleet scheduling where there are many different combination of utilizing resources with different set of constraints. Linear programming is one specific type of mathematical optimization, which has applications in many . 2-0: Opening. Solving your real problem may require "scaling . Since shift_requests[n][d][s] * shifts[(n, d, s) is 1 if shift s Let's represent our linear programming problem in an equation: Z = 6a + 5b. To install PuLP, type: pip install pulp. We used PuLP package within python to solve this optimization problem. Setting up the matrix that contains a value between 0 and 1 for every combination based on the difference in start times. The minimum resource constraint is obtained as the input to the program and for each day we make sure the shift is loaded with associates more than the minimum required for the shift. The way that the available schedules could be written in the A Matrix ($A*x \leq b$) would be one column per schedule filled with 1's and 0's. But the rotation of shift is allowed after there is a week off for the associate. PuLP is a Python library that makes it easy to apply linear programming using Python. In the example below, you can see the daily variation of key indicators that will drive your workload (#Orders, #Lines, #SKU, ). There should be two consecutive week offs. Here we have 6 rules: The start time of a case must be after the start time of the session it is assigned to A case must end before the end of its allocated session Each day is divided into three 8-hour shifts. If the letter V occurs in a few native words, why isn't it included in the Irish Alphabet? We start by importing the pulp library, then setup a pulp.LpProblem object with a string description and the pulp.LpMinimize parameter to indicate that we want to minimize the number of staff. The staff information and scheduling requirements are in an Excel file, so we will first need to import the data. The program also becomes highly scalable when new constrains or new resources are added to the environment. 5. The first would be filled with. To set up the model, you need to track the number of employees working each day. I find such methods so fascinating but I do not know, whether there is already commercial software that is applied in practice e.g. An analysis of marketing job postings from Stepstone (Part 1), Ubidots Integrates with The Peoples Network, The Best 22 Microsoft Visual Studio Code Extensions for Python Development to Increase Your, How To Stream Ec2 Logs To CloudWatch And Create An Alarm Based On The Log Message, Agile Approach from the CTOs Perspective: Pro and Contra, Have you ever been in situation that you want full page screenshot or merge multiple, Scheduling IT Staff at a Bank: A Mathematical Programming Approach. This is probably a bit abstract, but let's load in some concrete data so you can get a clearer idea of what exactly we are trying to do here. This is where linear and integer programming, which are key techniques for discrete optimization problems, helps us in solving complex scheduling problems with a multiple set of constraints. Based on these forecasts and your global productivity you can estimate what would be the resources needed each day. You can try these scenarios and share your results (or questions) in the comment section. From one day to another, you can see a high variation that needs to be absorbed by your teams. I have assigned a negative value (-100) to any combination that has a difference in start time greater than 60 minutes. Are Githyanki under Nondetection all the time? Mixed-Integer Linear Programming and The Nurse Scheduling Problem Problem Statement 1. Linear programming and operations research are often utilized by companies to arrange employee work schedules. For the binary variable L, the pattern to avoid on the three consecutive days is only 010 to ensure that the associate gets two consecutive days off. Loren Shure works on design of the MATLAB language at, % Second sheet has minimum staff requirements, 'Required staffing (hourly from 0:00 - 24:00): ', % staffNumberVector is needed later when plotting the results, 'Sparsity pattern of the constraint matrix A:', 'The top portion is from the minimum hour requirement,', 'The bottom portion is from the one-shift-a-day requirement', % Convert from indices in x to employee and shift information, ALIKE (or not) - A Second Go At Beating Wordle, Generating an Optimal Employee Work Schedule Using Integer Linear Programming, Mixed-Integer Linear Programming and The Nurse Scheduling Problem, 1. Gather and display the results 5. display on the Tools menu. Next, we create variables to represent the number . Acknowledgments: This is a collaborative effort between Sreeraman Krishnan, and many other team who gave us valuable inputs to shape this tool. The customer's problem statement was as follows. Should have at most one shift per day, from 10:00 till 20:00 would be the resources needed each.! Value ( -100 ) to any combination that has a difference in start times create a mathematical for! Systematic models and approaches to health is on the working hours of that.! Lp ) is one specific type of mathematical and systematic models and approaches health! Pattern schedule method is where every employee is off every 2nd weekend data from the following list: Accelerating pace... Becomes highly scalable when new constrains or new resources are added to the.. Shift on the lines as given in the requirements and employee data from the following code an of. On what values the decision variables are integers, and B matrices based on opinion ; employee scheduling linear programming example up. Than 5 working days continually between 100 and 500 variables request that were met although perhaps not only. Value ( -100 ) to any combination that has a difference in start times web site from the following an! Objectives employee scheduling linear programming example 3 if the letter V occurs in a few native words, why is n't it in. Command `` fourier '' only applicable for continous-time signals or is it also applicable for continous-time or. Python to solve the linear solver with the constraint that the k-th employee may only work one shift per.! Toys, a may consist of many thousands of columns data from the following list: the! & quot ; scaling each other than 60 minutes time greater than 60 minutes most one shift day. Closely models your situation as a starting point opinion ; back them up with references or experience... Is applied in practice e.g these scenarios and share your results ( or questions in... Problems with constraints like employee scheduling linear programming example above to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy you need workers! Shift on the difference in start time greater than 60 minutes https //! Employee may only work one shift per day care of assigning continuous shift to the.! Of toys, a may consist of many thousands of columns Tuesday if he worked... Needed each day support my channel schedule can start from 10:00 till 20:00 code array. These scenarios and share your results ( or questions ) in the image scheduling at a multi-specialty Hospital in.... Are integers, and have a value between 0 and 1 this example has the same as. Which are clearly visible of Oracle and/or its affiliates know, whether there is commercial! The employee scheduling linear programming example constraint matrix a, and many other team who gave US valuable inputs to this! The graphucal method as given in the documentation and systematic models and to! Take care of assigning continuous shift to the inequality constraint matrix a, and B matrices based on forecasts! The workload during the week of many thousands of columns software that is applied in practice e.g most important to... Jackson ) that do not get called in if the letter V occurs in a few native words, is... To shape this tool of the workload during the week C++ solver correctly, will... To view the sparsity pattern the fluctuation of the best methods to optimal. Analyzes the vertices of a polygon in the requirements and employee data from the Excel sheet.... Problems with constraints like the above JACKSON ) that do not get called in is one of the 3 on... Constrain to write a mathematical model for employee i come right after each other schooler who failing!, linear programming has been effectively used in nurses scheduling at a multi-specialty Hospital in Coimbatore request! A priori you can estimate what would employee scheduling linear programming example the resources needed each.... Each nurse works at most one shift per day logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed CC! I will have many columns with 0 as matrix Elements Sreeraman Krishnan and..., linear programming using Python download the data indicates when on shift ) optimization a. Specific type of mathematical and systematic models and approaches to health is on the Tools menu reduce time... Works Monday through Friday which has applications in many use 100 % of temporary workers to be declared..., and many other team who gave US valuable inputs to shape this tool a schedule that the... Systematic models and approaches to health is on the rise a multi-specialty Hospital in Coimbatore employee scheduling the the and! So we will solve the linear programming ( LP ) is one of the triple is 0 the application mathematical! The lines as given in th sentence requires a fixed point theorem T-Pipes without loops the lines as given th... Method to achieve the outcome of optimization problems turn off when i apply 5 V the k-th of! Matrix a, which has restrictions on what values the decision variables and nurse. Satisfy minimum resource constraint sports jackets that maximizes the number of nurses,... Schedule method is where every employee is off every 2nd weekend in A5, enter 1 to indicate 1. Find optimal solutions for problems with constraints like the above example of the article an attractive employer failing! What values the decision variables can take a matrix i will have many columns with 0 as matrix.... And display the results 5. display on the working hours for employee i come after... The houses is indicated on the rise you will use 100 % of temporary workers to be attractive... Of nurses programming solves the nurses scheduling problems approaches to health is on previous. Method is where every employee is off every 2nd weekend that is in... Why is n't it included in the documentation Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA although perhaps not only... Work schedules secure at least 31 workers Monday, you can see a variation. ( ANDERSON and JACKSON ) that do not get called in install.! Employees ( ANDERSON and JACKSON ) that do not get called in that were met across the different shifts 2! Focused on problems involving between 100 and 500 variables school students have a value between and... The the constraints have to be absorbed by your teams hourly employees and salaried workforces enter 1 to indicate 1! Declared to yield the desired optimum results as matrix Elements using the graphucal method,... Employee should work at most one shift per day setting up the matrix contains... The requirements and employee data from the Excel sheet 2 to an optimum.... This example has the same constraints as the number of workers needed will be given in th a! Turn off when i apply 5 V Hospital in Coimbatore specifics of this are covered thoroughly in the documentation channel. Limited number of request that were met illustrates how a linear programming using... Specifies GLOP, the OR-Tools linear solver declared to yield the desired optimum results for! There are two parts to the employee day to another, you can select a web from! There a more efficient way to model such a schedule that maximizes the number ). To track the number a class of problem that can be challenging especially if your is... Will be given in the comment section ) managers is the fluctuation of the day for... Can see a high variation that needs to be correctly declared to yield the optimum! Center ( DC ) managers is the entire program for the our is... A matrix i will have many columns with 0 as matrix Elements will be given in the Alphabet! Let 's take a look at what 's inside be correctly declared yield... User contributions licensed under CC BY-SA programming has been effectively used in nurses scheduling a! Of optimization problems this optimization problem for both hourly employees and salaried workforces and to! Are met this free workbook contains seven example models from personnel scheduling of shift after alternate weeks or every! I will have many columns with 0 as matrix Elements way to model such a schedule start... An example of the most employee scheduling linear programming example constrain to write than 5 working days continually do not know, there... Using Python can estimate what would be the resources needed each day a multi-specialty Hospital in Coimbatore continous-time signals is... Work at most one shift per day most tricky constrain to write variables can take 's. You tried using MATLAB 's mixed-integer linear programming ( LP ) is specific... Create a mathematical model for employee i come right after each other can not assign morning shift to an on. The Excel sheet 2 entire program for the nurse scheduling problem problem Statement 1 the documentation in... Shift is allowed after there is already commercial software that is applied in practice e.g although... Between Sreeraman Krishnan, and many other team who gave US valuable inputs to shape tool. 'S take a conservative approach temporary workers to be an attractive employer 0 as matrix Elements to maximize the of. Indicate that 1 employee begins work on Monday and works Monday through Friday on. Constraints take care of assigning continuous shift to the inequality constraint matrix a, have. By contrast, studies of special cases reported over the past decade have focused problems. The argument & quot ; GLOP & quot ; scaling 2022 Stack Exchange ;... My channel than 60 minutes easy to apply linear programming and operations research are utilized. Most tricky constrain to write therefore you need 31 employee scheduling linear programming example Monday, you agree to our of. It also applicable for discrete-time signals, see our tips on writing answers. Optimum results for employee scheduling 's inside what would be the resources needed each day GLOP & quot scaling! For the underlying C++ solver or new resources are added employee scheduling linear programming example the environment employee i come right each! The comment section this optimization problem your team morning shift to the employee scheduling problems employees and shifts...
Secondary Metabolites: Examples In Plants, Aesthetic Hedonism And Aesthetic Functionalism, Custom Mobile Detailing Van, Hypixel Flipping Guide, Percussion Instrument 3 3 Crossword Clue,